Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Modern Comfort Foods

Made Entirely From Scratch

Winter Warmers

Warm up with our rotating schedule of hot entrees, great for lunch or dinner. Available at 11 am until sold out

November 15th - April 15th

Concluded for the season!

Summertime Staples

Made to order custom sandwiches available every day during our open hours, starting at 11AM, May through October.

We take food allergies & preferences seriously and can always make accommodations as needed, whether dairy- nut- or gluten-free.

Boxed with chips and a chocolate chip cookie or an apple, perfect for your picnic!

no substitutions please

SIGNATURE SANDWICHES


Italian Stallion:  salami, ham, capicola, provolone, giardinera, lettuce, tomato, red onion, oil & vinegar, kaiser

Gold Standard:  roasted turkey, swiss, avocado, mayo, lettuce, tomato, wheat bread

Hammy:  smoked ham, cheddar, mayo, white bread

New Yorker:  pastrami, swiss, house pickles, brown mustard, seeded rye bread

Plant Parent:  hummus, pepper jack, cucumber, red onion, lettuce, tomato, avocado, oil & vinegar, seeded rye bread 

MAKE IT YOUR OWN

CUSTOM SANDWICH OPTIONS

Breads:  white, wheat, kaiser, seeded rye, wrap, gluten-free, lettuce wrap

Condiments:  butter, mayo, horsey mayo, yellow mustard, brown mustard, honey mustard, oil & vinegar

Veggies:  lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber, house pickles, giardinera, add avocado

Cheeses:  pepper jack, swiss, american, provolone, cheddar

Meats:  turkey, ham, salami, capicola, pastrami, roast beef, chicken salad, tuna salad, sub avocado for meat

Made to order sandwiches have been a Fish Creek Market staple for decades, first offered by the Norz Family at a time when most summer residents of Fish Creek didn't have refrigeration of their own.  We're proud to continue the tradition with a fully-customizable option, as well as a menu of Market Signature Sandwiches.

Call-ahead orders are always welcome, and especially encouraged for large groups!  

920-868-3351