Your cart

Your cart is empty

Modern Comfort Foods

Made Entirely From Scratch

Winter Warmers

Delicious options to take and heat during the quiet winter season

November 15th - April 15th

Coming soon!

Summertime Staples

Made to order custom sandwiches are available every day May through October: 

Tuesday-Saturday 11am-3pm 

Sunday & Monday 11am-2pm 

Pick-up outside of these hours is available for pre-orders by request.

We take food allergies & preferences seriously and can always make accommodations as needed, whether dairy- nut- or gluten-free.

Boxed with chips and a chocolate chip cookie or an apple, perfect for your picnic!

Made to order sandwiches have been a Fish Creek Market staple for decades, first offered by the Norz Family at a time when most summer residents of Fish Creek didn't have refrigeration of their own.  We're proud to continue the tradition with a fully-customizable option, as well as a menu of Market Signature Sandwiches.

Call-ahead orders are always welcome, and especially encouraged for large groups!  

920-868-3351